The Buffalo Hunt by James Fontana
(Somewhat revised by his mother
Estelle, after presenting his version at school- third grade)
My Grandfather went to South
Dakota on a buffalo hunt when he was about 19 or 20 years old. It was during
the Gold Rush to the Black Hills. The white men killed many buffalo just for
sport and the Indians did not like it because they were killing off the buffalo
which the Indians needed for food, clothing, shelter, and weapons. The Indians
also thought the white men were very clumsy hunters.
I do not know how Grandfather
first met Chief Yellowbird, but the chief knew that Grandfather was a very good
rider. One time Grandfather met Chief Yellowbird and about 50 Indians when they
were going to hunt buffalo. Chief Yellowbird invited Grandfather to hunt with
them. Grandfather was very pleased because the Indians never let white men hunt
buffalo with them. Grandfather knew he would have to do what the Indians did
and follow the Chief's instructions.
First he took the saddle and
blanket off his horse. Then he took off his clothes wearing only his cartridge
belt and carrying his gun.
The Indians formed a long line,
one behind the other, with Chief Yellowbird at the head. At first they trotted
easily until the chief signaled them to stop. He had sighted the buffalo
grazing. They then proceeded at a slow, quiet walk .. still in single file ..
until they had circled around so the buffalo were between them and the
direction of the wind so the buffalo would not get their scent and start
running.
Chief Yellowbird signaled again
and each hunter turned his pony toward the buffalo. Now they were in one long
line riding
abreast .. still slowly and quietly.
They proceeded this way--closing in on the herd until the first buffalo raised
his head, gave a warning snort and started the herd moving. Then with a yell
the chief signaled for the stampede and every pony broke into a wild gallop
into the buffalo herd. It was a serious and dangerous game. There is just one
place to shoot a buffalo to fell it quickly. That is right behind the left fore
leg. You can see that is not an easy shot for a target running wildly and from
a pony on a fast gallop. But to wound a buffalo and not kill it was asking for
death. A wounded buffalo was likely to turn and charge horse and rider and in
that mass of wild animals one could only hope his pony could outrun the enraged
buffalo. It was no boy's game and only those who were sure of their ability to
shoot took part in it.
Each Indian killed one buffalo
and when his buffalo fell, the hunter dropped a moccasin beside it as he rode
by. Later, after he rode back to camp, his squaw came and identified his
buffalo by the moccasin. As Grandfather had no moccasin to mark his kill, they
knew his buffalo was the one not marked. Grandfather gave his buffalo to Chief
Yellowbird to be cooked for a feast for his people as a token of. thanks for
letting him ride with them.
Of course the chief invited
him to the feast, but Grandfather had to ride on to Deadwood. This was an honor
that was accorded to very few white men. It was a very high compliment for the
Indians to pay to Grandfather's riding and hunting ability.
(I might add
that every bit of the buffalo was used by the Indians.' The hides for tee pees,
clothes, boots, straps etc. The horns for powder horns, dippers etc. The bones
for tools scrapers, needles, etc. Nothing was wasted. The most buffaloes killed
by white men, were killed by buffalo hunters for the army. They just took the
hump which was the choicest meat and left the rest. This naturally angered the
Indians to see this waste
of one of their main resources.)
“Jailer Days” as told by Estelle Fontana
“When Dad decided he wanted to
stay in the Black Hills of South Dakota, he looked for a job. They had a
dangerous prisoner in the jail (in Deadwood) and needed another man for the
night shift, so Dad got the job. A Mr. Leighton was in jail at that time and
was considered very dangerous. He had killed four men. He as the reason they
needed another man. Dad asked for the key to go into the room where the
prisoners were kept. The jailer said, "Don't go in there!” ff
Dad said, "How can I do my
job if I'm afraid to go in there?"
He took the keys to go in. The
jailer unlocked the door, then locked it again after Dad. He could hardly
believe what he saw. Leighton was chained hand and foot to a bench. He just
scowled at Dad. Dad went over to him and saw that his wrists and ankles were
swollen over the irons. Dad went to the door and asked for the keys to the
irons and a basin of warm soapy water. Fellows outside said, "You're crazy,
he will kill you." But they did give him the keys and the water, but they
locked the door after him again. Dad took off the irons and bathed his wrists
and ankles and messaged them.
He thought he saw a tear in
Leighton's eyes. He said, "Thank God, there's one human being here."
Dad got him to walk around and
exercise. He became very friendly and he and Dad would have long talks to while
away the long hours. Leighton admitted he was getting what he deserved. He
didn't blame anyone but himself. He said it was his uncontrolled temper. He
said each of the four men had wronged him, but they didn't deserve to die. Dad
really liked the man.
When the time came for Leighton
to be hanged, he asked Dad, "Do you think you could get me the rope?"
When Dad asked why he said, “f I want to be sure who ever ties that
knot knows how to do it right." You see, he didn't want to hang and choke
to death - the knot should break his neck. Dad was able to bring him the rope. So,
Leighton himself, tied the knot that broke his neck the very next day. That
same knot is on display today at the Adams Museum, in Deadwood, South Dakota.”
****
JAILER DAYS
"Unusual Weapons" as
told by Estelle Fontana
“Dad often had to go to the saloon to break up a fight or put
someone in jail until he sobered up. Mostly on Saturday nights when the cowboys
came in with their week's pay. Dad, of course, had a gun but didn't usually
wear it. He believed the best way to get shot was to wear a gun. He also was
more concerned about killing someone than being killed himself. He had two
English bull dogs. He said they looked fierce but wouldn't hurt a mouse.
Whenever he had to bring someone into jail, he would take the dogs along
instead of his gun.
"Come on, I'm taking you to jail until you sober up," he
would tell the guy stirring up the trouble.
"Who's going to take me??" was often the reply along
with a dirty look and a fist ready to hit Dad.
"Take'em Boys!" dad would yell at the dogs. The dogs
would each grab a pant leg and pull until the guy sat down ---HARD! After that
the guy would step on his heels to get
into the jail away from the dogs. The dogs loved this game.
One time when the jail was full, one of the inmates asked Dad to
let the dogs in because there was a mouse in there they thought the dogs could
get. So, Dad let the dogs in and locked the door. But it sounded like all H
..... broke loose. When Dad opened the door, every man was downed, and the dogs
were looking at him very self-satisfied.
They didn't understand they were sent in- just for a little old
mouse!”
***
JAILER DAYS
"A NEW SUIT OF CLOTHES"
as told by his daughter Estelle Fontana
“In Deadwood, many men were without their families; such as
miners, adventurers, cowboys, you name it. Some literally "ended up"
in jail and 'ended up" dying there. In that case they were given a new
suit of clothes to be buried in. I don't know who provided it; the town; the
territorial government or who.
There were two brothers Ike and Jake who had a tailor shop. Dad
thought up a scheme to give them a scare. He sent someone to tell Ike one of
the inmates had died and he wanted to make a suit for him for burial. Ike came
to measure the man who was "laid out" on the table looking very dead.
Ike carefully measured him but when he measured his chest the dead man raised
up and grabbed Ike in a tight embrace. Poor Ike froze. When everyone laughed,
he recovered. The "dead man" got off the table, but Ike said
"No, no ... somebody, go get Jake."
So, the little drama was repeated, but Jake didn't freeze. He gave
the "corpse" a terrific blow to the face and ran out the door and
down the street out of sight. They later found him in the black- smith shop.
The blacksmith wondered what the poor man had seen. Dad realized then that
sometimes a good joke can backfire, but it must have been funny at the time.
Dad would laugh so much he could hardly tell this story.”
"Your Horses or Your Scalp?"
“When Dad was living in Deadwood
South Dakota, he had many responsibilities.
Dad had to go down Spearfish
Valley to bring back the body of a Mr. Deffenbaugh who was killed by Indians.
Spearfish valley was the last battleground for the Sioux and the Crow Indians.
There were still sporadic raids and the Indians were also protesting the White
man's invasion of the Black Hills. People were very cautious if they had to
leave Deadwood. Dad and another man, wrapped the wagon wheels and the horses’
feet with gunny sacks and left at night hoping the Indians would not see or
hear them. They thought they would be back before daylight. However, they
didn't make it before daylight. When crossing the flat land before the hill to
Deadwood they saw a band of about 50 Indians riding toward them. The other man
readied his gun to shoot. Dad grabbed his gun and pushed it down yelling at
him, "What are you doing? What chance would we have ... two of us and
about 50 of them?!!!"
"Well, I'd take a couple
with me anyway."
"If we just stay calm and
wait for them, they might not do anything," Dad replied.
Reason prevailed and when the
Indians approached, Dad recognized his friend, Yellow Bird. He wanted to know
what they were doing out of Deadwood. When they explained their reason, Yellow
Bird said they had better let him escort them to Deadwood. So they did .... to
where the road went downhill into Deadwood. Yellow Bird said they should have
their horses for the safe escort to Deadwood. So, Dad unhitched the horses and
gave them to the Indians. His friend was furious!
To which Dad simply replied:
"Would you rather lose the horses or your
scalp?"”
***
"THE BATTLE OF THE LITTLE
BIGHORN"
"Earlier in his career, Custer had
been friendly with the Indians and had even become a "blood brother."
No Indian would have killed him. They knew him well as "Yellow Hair."
D.S. Billington said three Indian Chiefs told him what really happened, and he
thoroughly believed them.
Custer was conceited and took his
own way disregarding any advice. He was put out of the Army for this, but when
the Army planned a campaign against the Indians, they recalled him because he
was experienced. Custer was glad to be reinstated. They planned to encircle the
Indian forces. Custer would come from one side and General Reno from the other
side and meet at the Little Bighorn. Custer got there first and saw that the
Indian force was small. Thinking he could finish them off quickly he didn't
wait for Reno. He underestimated the Indians and was caught in the trap they
had set.
His men were killed, and Custer
was disgraced. History books all say Custer was the last man standing. D.S.
said that the reason he was the last one standing is because they wouldn't kill
him, he killed himself and saved himself from saying he made a terrible
mistake.
A book D.S. Billington read from cover to cover over
and over was "The Last Hunting Ground" by Annie Talent. She described
South Dakota accurately as it was during his time there."
****
"Crow Dog"--(story also appeared on an earlier post)
"When the Dakotas became a territory, officials, anxious to.establish law and order (and give the new circuit courts something to do), rounded up all known criminals, including Chief Crow Dog, who had killed Chief Spotted Tail.
My father, D. S. Billington, was the jailer in Deadwood at that time. Some years prior and at the invitation of Chief Yellow Bird, my father had hunted with the Indians. Few white men had this privilege. He came to have a great respect and admiration for the Indians. He and Crow Dog became friends.
Crow Dog had an arrow wound in one lung. Dad, knowing also how painful it was for an Indian to be caged, told Crow Dog that he would let him out during the day if he would return at sunset every evening to be locked up for the night. My father had absolute faith that an Indian would keep his word to a friend, not necessarily to anyone else,, but defnitely to a friend. So, with one of my father's two English bulldogs, Crow Dog would go up to White Rocks every day and return at sunset every evening. This went on for nearly four years.
Most people expected the day would come when Crow Dog would not return, but Dad's faith in him never wavered. The wait Crow Dog endured was unusually long for a man accused of 'a crime which carried a sentence of death. Crow Dog was sure he would eventually be hanged according to white man's law. The reason for the long wait was that there was no one to defend him. No one wanted to take a losing case.
One day Dad and another man had to go down Spearfish valley to pick up the body of a man killed by the Indians (that's another good story.) Crow Dog overheard their plans. That evening Crow Dog and the dog did not return. People were sure their predictions had come true.
When Dad returned, he was soundly reprimanded, but he still believed that Crow Dog would eventually return. He probably went to the Reservation to tell his people good-bye. Not having Dad's faith in Indians, the Marshall sent a man named Billy to bring back Crow Dog. I don't remember how many days had passed before Crow Dog came hack to Deadwood alone. When asked where Billy was, Crow Dog answered,. "I don't know any Billy. I left by myself. I came back by myself."
Dad asked him about his dog. Crow Dog said, "Sorry, I ate it."
In the meantime a young lawyer in Boston named Plowman had heard about this "strange" case. Not knowing anything about the West other than tales he had heard, he thought that it would be quite a lark (and some publicity) to go West and take this case. He went to the Reservation and talked to many Indians. He learned that Crow Dog had been tried by the tribal council and that he had been exonerated by them. At Crow Dog's long awaited trial young Plowman proved that this was double jeopardy, and Crow Dog was freed.
Unlike the television rendition of this story, the people of Deadwood were glad that Crow Dog was set free. They had come to like this Indian who had been quite a fixture in Deadwood. Many had to admit that Crow Dog had taught them an unforgettable lesson in honor. '"
